Quality Diaper Products for the Tiny and Not so Tiny Hinnies.

Cloth vs. Disposable

Why use cloth diapers?

This is one of the most common questions out there for new or soon to be moms today. Unlike our mothers and grandmothers cloth diapering is easier and has more options than even 15 years ago. Which is better? What is more cost efficient? Which is easier? These are all questions many moms ask. I will try my best to answer why I believe cloth diapering is the best option.

Average diaper use for each child based on 2 ½ years of diapering is approximately 9,100 diaper changes. This is if you change your infant every 2-3 hours and your toddler is changed every 3-4 hours.

Based on 9,100 diaper changes in a 2 ½ year period here is the breakdown.

Disposable Diapers

· Disposable diapers range from .22 - .45 cents per diaper depending on brand and size.
· This would be an average of .34 cents per diaper
· .34 cents times 9,100 diapers is a total of $3,094
*Note: you may be able to find a cheaper diaper or your child may potty train faster than 2 ½ yrs. It is also possible that your child needs diapers longer.

Cloth Diaper Service

· Diaper service cost anywhere from $50 - $85 per week
· This would be an average of $65 per week
· $65 per week times 2 ½ yrs is a total of $8450
*Note: some diaper services may be cheaper or you will need fewer diapers so the average cost would go down.

Buying & Washing Your Own

Buying your own diapers can vary in price from $50 to $1500. It depends on if you make your own, buy used, or new. Then if you are buying new are you buying the posh brands or just the economy brands? For this I will take the average of the range, which is $775 to fully outfit your diapering needs.

Washing your own diapers also varies depending on the type of washing machine you use and how many times a week you wash your diapers. Consumer Reports estimates that the most inefficient washer and dryer system cost approximately .78 cents per load, whereas more efficient models cost approximately .44 cents per load. This is an average of .61 cents per load (including water and electricity). Loads per week can vary from 2 – 4 loads per week for an average of 3 loads per week. Laundry soap also varies in price from .30 cents per load to .85 cents per load, this is an average of .58 cents per load.

· Up front diaper supplies average cost is approximately $775
· Average cost for 3 loads per week for 2 ½ years is $628.48
· This is a total average cost of $1403.48
*Note: these are based on averages for a more accurate cost breakdown look at the cost to run your washer/dryer and your laundry detergent.

Overall Cost Comparison

· Disposable Total $3,094
· Diaper Service Total $8450
· Buying & Washing your own total $1403.48
For overall cost washing your own diapers wins out by a landslide. Also important to note is that if you choose to have more than one child both disposable and diaper service costs will stay the same whereas washing your own will only be the cost of the washing since you can re-use all the diapers with your subsequent children. Your costs can also go down if you hang dry your diapers, which is very good for them. Lastly after all is said and done and your children are done with diapers you can sell them for someone else to use.

What about Convenience?

In many ways this is a personal preference. Some find the ease of a disposable to be great on day outings because you don’t need a dirty diaper bag. For others it is the same, you have to change a dirty diaper either way. Traveling has been the biggest challenge for most; finding a place to wash your diapers is not always easy and making sure you have the laundry soap you prefer can be tedious. Others find this to be a normal part of the packing process, bring some soap and make sure there are laundry facilities where you are staying.

If you choose cloth there are many great diaper bags and accessories for a mom on the go. Not only are they cute but highly functional. When my children were in diapers I would pack my diaper bag with the diaper already in the cover so when it was time for a change all I needed to do was grab the clean one and put it on, slip the dirty one in the wet bag and off we went. While traveling we just brought a small amount of our laundry soap with us in a Tupperware and washed at families homes or made sure the hotel had a laundry room. If our trip were just for the weekend we would just wash the diapers when we got home.

What is Better?

Well now this is the question of the hour. In my humble opinion cloth is best. There is debate about washing your own diapers being just as harmful to our environment as using disposable but I really feel that this is stretching a bit. It is true that diaper service diapers do use many chemicals on the diapers to disinfect them but home washing really can be a small impact depending on the laundry soap you use and the efficiency of your washer/dryer. Not only that but to make a disposable they use water, and other chemicals that hurt or environment as well as the back end use of the diaper, they don’t break down in land fills and many people think it is okay to simply put the human fecal matter into the trash. This is not okay at all you are supposed to shake them out into the toilet before you throw them away. To me this is a double whammy, first your use toxins to make them then they are so durable that they stick around for years. It is true that there are some more enviromentally friendly disposables out there that don't use toxins to produce them and they break down in much less time, these are much more expensive and were not taken into consideration in our price comparison.

In addition to the above, many disposables use fragrances. Some parents and children alike don’t do well with fragrance. It can be that it gives them headaches, or rashes; rashes are sometimes caused by the chemicals used to produce the diapers as well; so many people need to pay attention when purchasing these. Many cloth diapering parents like that they can change what they wash the diapers in to help with rashes, so this gives them more control around what touches their babies skin. It is also said that children who use disposables tend to take longer in the potty training process because the lock away cores work so well they never really feel wet, whereas cloth diapered children can feel the wetness and potty train faster.

*Note: Some children continue to wet the bed at night till they are much older. These children have really large bladders and need something really absorbent so some parents (even devout cloth diapering parents) will opt to use disposables with their older children.

Home | Contact Us | About Us
Links | Why Cloth